Image Credit: quickblogcastThough I had all along heard of Agatha Christie and even read a couple of her books when I was in school I never really paid much attention to it. Recently, blogger friend Bina wrote a long and interesting piece on Christie, which made me think about reading one soon. And of course, Thoughts had been recommending that I read for a long time. So I borrowed two books from her and I finished one for which I thought I will write a small review. There’s not much I can say that has not been said about Christie!
The Murder on the Links is a Hercule Poirot mystery and I must say I did enjoy this one a lot. Poirot and his friend Arthur Hastings are called away to France to solve the murder of Renauld a millionaire. Just when he thinks he has got a hold on the incident, there occurs another murder, which makes the whole case more perplexing.
I loved the way Christie created a lot of twists and turns in the plot to throw the reader off balance. Poirot of course hardly ever seemed off kilter! Being an ardent Sherlock Holmes fan, I couldn’t help comparisons. I felt Holmes’ cases don’t have as many twists or elements to them. They are a bit more simplistic. At least for me, I could usually guess the culprit, though I couldn’t find the evidence. Holmes had to help me in that. In Christie, I was clueless. I really didn’t know who had done what. Because the plot kept throwing up new turns. Holmes’ friend Watson is more of an admirer and follower of Holmes than an active participant. Usually, he is the sounding board. Holmes expounds his theories and thoughts on the present case and Watson listens. Here, in Christie, Hastings is more of a participant. He does deduce things at times, though the clairvoyant Poirot would usually have seen those points in his mind already. I also observed that Hastings’ character is given much importance too. He is not just there as a presence, but he is an entity by himself. We learn of his own feelings, his thoughts. In other words, he has a personality of his own. He is a bit similar to Watson in that both love beautiful women and appreciate their beauty. But with Watson, it stops there. We don’t go too deep into his inner thoughts. With Hastings, we see a few different facets to him.
Well, these are just my two pence. I will always remain a Holmes fan. Even when I went to London, I had made up my mind that I would go see Holmes’ house on Baker Street even if I had to miss out on something else for lack of time! And I am glad I did, I freaked out! As for Christie, I have only read one book so far. Too early for fan status, but yes I see potential :)
Oh and please feel welcome to add to my comparisons here, I would be most interested to know!
Haha, finally you read Christie but you can't let go of your love! Oh SherlocK!
ReplyDeleteYou've read only one book so far, SNIFF! You have a lot of catching up to do with Agatha Christie.Some books are fantastic.
ReplyDeleteI like the genre of murder mystery- all of them. But my all time favorite is "Erle Stanley Gardener" of Perry Mason fame.Perry Mason books ARE THE BESTEST :)
Soul - Yes finally I read Christie! But Holmes my love :D Well, as I said I haven't read enough Christie so let's give the poor woman a break...
ReplyDeleteInscrutable - Goodness what are my eyes seeing! You actually commented instead of sneakily seeing all our reviews and going! :D Hehe do this more often! Yes I do want to read Perry Mason too, my dad also keeps recommending him highly. WIll get one from somewhere...
Great review this, telling everything yet revealing nothing!!
ReplyDeleteAs for comparing Sherlock/Doyle with Poirot/Christie - I don't know Bird, I think it would be like comparing oranges with apples. Poirot came on the scene decades later than Sherlock. By which time technology had advanced so much that Poirot didn't have to go about noticing the mud on the heels or the cigarette butts.
It was all about the "mind" by then, the "psychology of things" so to speak...
ohh forgot to mention - congrats on completing your first Christie novel!!!
ReplyDeleteYou are welcome to borrow many more, I reorganized all my books, so now I have a whole shelf dedicated to Christie :)
Thoughts - I know. Poirot doesn't look at footprints and such and he is quite condescendingly vociferous about it to poor Hastings. But as I said, this is only the first. Let me read a few more and then decide if my Holmes' position is challenged :D
ReplyDeleteI have never read Agatha Christie. I really should.
ReplyDeleteVaishnavi - If you like mysteries, then don't leave out Christie :) My friends here are huge fans and they will give you ample suggestions if you wish :D
ReplyDeleteOoh, I adore that edition!!! :) Great review, and yay for finally reading Agatha Christie (you'll be busy for a couple if years now ;)).
ReplyDeleteChristie copied the Holmes/ Watsin thing with Poirot/ Hastings but she made it better ;) I started with Christie so poor Sherlock never had a chance. Though his stories are nice, too.
Bina - I guess I will be busy! I do want to read more of her books to get a feel of them. I am right now reading a Miss Marple, again that Thoughts lent me. I find this a bit more fascinating than the previous one so far... :)
ReplyDeleteGlad to know that you enjoyed your first (or nearly first) Christie book, Birdy :) I am a big Christie fan! I haven't read this book yet, and I love the cover and the fact that the action is set on a golf link. Looking forward to reading this. Two of my favourite Christies are 'And then there were none' (amazing!) and 'The Murder of Roger Ackroyd' (Most amazing!). If you do get a chance to read these books, I would love to hear your thoughts on them :)
ReplyDeleteI love Holmes too and have read 'A Study in Scarlet' so many times. Which is your favourite Holmes book?
Vishy - Yes nearly first is a good term lol :D I enjoyed it. Now I finished the second book and will be posting a review now. Hm, I will look out for the 2 books you recommended. Am sure Thoughts will have it in her vast Christie collection :D
ReplyDeleteHolmes, as of now remains in situ as my hero :D Oh to choose my favorite is difficult - I loved Speckled Band, read a couple of times. Then, Hound of Baskervilles, Sign of Four and The Final Problem... Glad you love Holmes too! :D
'The Hound of the Baskervilles' is really wonderful! It is actually a universal favourite in my home :) 'The Speckled Band' is also quite wonderful! Do you remember the story 'The Greek Interpreter' where Holmes' brother Mycroft makes an appearance? I loved Mycroft's style of detection too :)
ReplyDeleteDid you get to see the movie 'Sherlock Holmes' which came out recently, which had Robert Downey Jr. as Holmes and Jude Law as Watson? It had a melange of features from all the stories put together with a new plot but it was fun to watch. I also liked the character of Irene Adler, portrayed in the movie.
Vishy - Yes I do remember Greek Interpreter...Mycroft's way is kind of different right? :) No, haven't seen the movie yet though many ppl have urged me to do so :) Irene Adler was the one woman who outwitted Holmes and who Holmes admired... :D
ReplyDelete