![]() |
| Image Credit: Amazon |
Anyway, as I stepped into the 20s, I think I became a little better. I substituted snob for shy, and bravado for cowardice. It worked. People think I am a snob. And mistake me for being aggressively confident. When I saw Giulio Cesare Giacobbe's How To Become A Buddha In 5 Weeks, I picked it up for one reason only - I am a fan of the Buddha. Not in a religious, "I bow to thee," way, but let's just say he and I have had a beautiful friendship the past few years. Giacobbe's book tries to simplify Buddhism, and tries to present some of the Buddha's precepts and teachings in a simple, easy to understand and identify manner. I am all for simplification - I never understood why it should be so hard to reach this phenomenon called God, if so much of the world thinks God is so important. Too much of religion comes packed with guidelines, dogmas and vague rules, which is why I stay away from it. Giacobbe takes us through the Buddha's 8-fold path, and argues that it should be whittled down to 5 in the end. Two he ignores, which means that all that is left is to perform the 3 actions.
I liked Giacobbe's easy to understand style - but there are very little practical exercises. Apart from saying 'breathe' and a few choice phrases of visualization as a mantra, there is precious little that is new. I know that I will not become a Buddha in 5 weeks. You know that too. Everyone knows that. But it is possible to become a better human being in 5 weeks. Some of Giacobbe's principles may help you. Others are plain hyperbole. He ruins it completely in the end when he talks of unconditional love and compares it to a mother's love. Seriously?Perhaps he hasn't heard of the 1000s of cases where mothers have willingly tortured and abused their child. Yes, even fathers too. Where did 'unconditional love' go then? To me, that's a myth. Love. That's enough. Let's not tag a label to it and call it unconditional.
And some of his references are well, dodgy. He quotes the Dalai Lama as saying that “…the Buddha is inside you whatever you do and wherever you go.” and then says "I don’t know where and when he said it but, given the Buddha’s pot belly, he must have said it somewhere! (p. 26)". Try passing an academic paper, Mr Giacobbe with those sort of references. Having said that, there is a little wisdom in the book. As with life, take what comes with a little bit of salt. And perhaps a little spice. Sweeten it up if you must. But don't swallow it whole.
Verdict: Just about O.K.
Rating: 2/5

I cannot agree more with the religion and mother's love statements. Both are overhyped. But sounds like a fun book! :D And I don't believe this bit either - "lacking intelligence"
ReplyDeleteNice review, Soul! I liked very much your observation - "I am a fan of the Buddha...I have had a beautiful friendship the past few years" :)
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting that Giacobbe takes the Buddha's 8-fold path and simplifies it into three actions. It reminds me of the Ten Commandments in Christianity, which had a lot of 'Thou shalt not's and which Jesus Christ simplified into 'Love your God and Love your neighbour'.
It was interesting to read your thoughts on unconditional love. I am an old-fashioned romantic and I believe that it exists :) Maybe it is becoming scarce these days, but I have definitely seen this old friend around.
Birdy, you are welcome to borrow it from me any time.
ReplyDeleteVishy, haha, it's good if you have seen that old friend around. We should have an interesting discussion on it, someday, no?
Yes, we should have an interesting conversation about this old friend, sometime :)
ReplyDelete@Soul and Birdy : I love the new tabs on top and the round, soft edges LFW had got now. I was wondering that something had changed but couldn't pinpoint it, but after some careful looking, I found them :)
ReplyDeleteWhat happened to Thoughts? She seems to be very quiet these days. And wasn't there a Life Wordsmither called Wishful Vandy?
@Vishy - Thanks, I redid the design yesterday, glad you noticed.
ReplyDeleteAs for Thoughts - I have no idea, she has disappeared...is not in touch with us.
That person called Wistful Vandy, unfortuately, didn't turn out to be a human being at all. I am rarely harsh like this, but lets just say, it will take a while for me to get rid of the pain she inflicted.
I think the Buddha is very interesting too, but this book sounds a bit too wacky for me!
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you enjoyed Half of a Yellow Sun too. I've just bought Purple Hibiscus and can't wait to read it!
@Sam : Purple Hibiscus was brilliant. That author is just amazing, I am in awe of her!
ReplyDeleteHope Thoughts resurfaces soon.
ReplyDeleteSorry to know about Wistful Vandy.
I love your new avatar picture :)
I know next to nothing about The Buddha or Bhuddhism actually. I have Hermann Hesse's Siddartha sitting in my shelf for a while and I should probably have gotten to it a lot sooner! This has served as something of a booster actually. I agree with your views on religion, it sort gets lost in all the hoopla that surrounds it! Back here after a long long time! Was sick for a while and stayed away from blogging for almost six months.....it is good to be back :)
ReplyDelete